DJ v Secretary of State for Work and pensions and TJ (CSM) (Child support- receipt of benefit) [2017] UKUT 83 (AAC)

14th February 2017

Appeal considering whether a liability to pay child maintenance should end when a child begins full time employment

Facts:

  • The appellant is a non-resident parent who was liable to be assessed for child support maintenance in respect of a qualifying child, K.
  • Child benefit for K had remained in payment until K was 19, and the body administering child support maintenance (‘the agency’) had only terminated the appellant’s liability once child benefit was no longer paid.
  • The appellant argued that K had been working full time since September 2014, and that if child benefit was being paid, it was an error. His obligation to pay should therefore have been terminated.
  • The first tier tribunal confirmed the agency’s decision as child support liability is linked to the payment of child benefit and not the commencement of employment.

Held:

  • JF v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions & DB (CSM) [2013] UKUT 209 (AAC) previously held that the phrase “payable” in paragraph 1A of Schedule 1 of the Child Support Maintenance Calculation Procedure Regulations 2000, which states “a person in respect of whom child benefit is payable”, meant “properly or lawfully payable.”
  • Despite the legislative changes to Schedule 1 since JF (on 10 December 2012), the relevant definition of a child in relation ‘a person in respect of whom child benefit is payable’ remained in identical form. The conditions from JF therefore continue to apply.
  • The tribunal fell into error of law in failing to investigate the father’s contention that K was working, as it was relevant under the Child Benefit regulations.
  • Where there is a suggestion, which is not fanciful, that child benefit was not properly or lawfully payable, it should be investigated by a child support tribunal. This was not a simple matter, however.
  • The District Tribunal Judge was invited to consider joining HMRC as a party, so they could make an informed decision as to the period for which child benefit was properly and lawfully payable.

Stay Up To Date

Follow us on Linkedin to stay up to date with the latest news from 1 Hare Court.