Yesterday, the Court of Appeal handed down judgment in the linked appeals of Morgan v Antoniou and Morrell v Morgan.
Nicholas Wilkinson KC, Phillip Blatchly and Henrietta Boyle successfully acted for Ms Antoniou in the first appeal, instructed by Miranda Fisher, David Carver and Isobel Asti of Charles Russell Speechlys.
Christie O’Connell appeared as junior counsel for Mr Morgan in both appeals, instructed by Laura Guillon and Emma Whitehead of Hall Brown Family Law.
In a landmark decision, it was held that a court ‘top-up’ child maintenance order does not cease to have effect upon the Child Maintenance Service issuing later review, revision or supersession decisions, and that instead one single maintenance calculation (which is merely varied by later decisions) continues following the Child Maintenance Service providing an initial assessment.
The Court of Appeal’s judgment confirms that the argument previously made by non-resident parents that later decisions made by the Child Maintenance Service extinguish a court top-up order is not in fact correct in law. This judgment provides much needed certainty and security for resident parents who no longer need to worry about whether a court top-up order is going to be brought to an end by a subsequent Child Maintenance decision.
